COACT
PubMed • Full text • PDF
Clinical Question
In patients with out of hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) and successful resuscitation and absence of ST elevation MI, is survival better with immediate or delayed angiography?
Bottom Line
Major Points
Several small and large randomized trials in diabetics had previously suggested a sizable benefit of tight glycemic control in reducing cardiovascular risk. The ACCORD trial was the largest study of its kind and demonstrated that not only does euglycemia (ie, HbA1c <6%) not reduce cardiovascular risk, it also is associated with a trend towards increased mortality.
Guidelines
Design
- Multicenter, open-label, parallel-group, randomized, controlled trial
- N= 552
- Immediate angiography (n= 273)
- Delayed angiography (n= 265)
- Setting: 19 centers in the Nederlands
- Enrollment: January 2015 to June 2018
- Follow-up: 90 days
- Analysis: Intention-to-treat
- Primary outcome: 90 day survival
Population
Inclusion Criteria
- Age > 18
- Out of Hospital Cardiac Arrest with ROSC (GSC < 8)
- Comatose
- Ventricular fibrillation or ventricular tachycardia as initial arrest rhythm
Exclusion Criteria
- Signs of STEMI on the ECG at the emergency department (including new LBBB or
isolated ST depression in V1-V3 due to an true posterior infarct).
- Hemodynamic instability unresponsive to medical therapy. Defined as a prolonged (>30 min) systolic blood pressure < 100 mm Hg at the time of screening.
- An obvious or suspected non cardiac aetiology of the cardiac arrest.
- A known severe renal dysfunction. (GRF< 30 ml/min)
- Obvious or suspected pregnancy
- Suspected or confirmed acute intracranial bleeding
- Suspected or confirmed acute stroke
- Known limitations in therapy or DO Not Resuscitate-order.
- Known pre-arrest Cerebral Performance Category 3 or 4
- >4 hours (240 min from ROSC to screening)
- Refractory ventricular arrhythmia
- Known inability to complete 90 day follow up*
Baseline Characteristics
- Immediate Angiography vs Delayed Angiography
- Mean age: 65.7 v 64.9
- Male: 81.7 v 76.2%
- HTN 48.7 v 47.5%
- Previous MI 26.7 v 28.7%
- Previous CABG 12.8 v 9.1%
- Previous PCI 16.9 v 22.7%
- Previous CAD 36.8 v 36.2%
- Prior CVA 7.0 v 5.7%
- DM 20.2 v 16.6%
- Current smoker 20.1 v 26.9%
- HLD 25.9 v 29.7%
- PAD 5.9 v 8.7%
- Arrest witnessed 79.9 v 76.6%
- Time to BLS 2 v 2 minutes
- Time to ROSC 15 v 15
- Ischemic ECG
- Mean GCS at admision 3 v 3
- APACHE IV score 107 v 105
- Baseline labs
- pH 7.2 v 7.2
- Lactic acid 5.3 v 4.9
- Bicarbonate 19.4 v 19.0
- Base excess -7.4 v -7.7
- pO2 14.7 v 15.3
- Mixed venous spO2 94 v 94%
- Cr umol/L 102 v 101
- CK ug/L 6 v 6.3
- Troponin T ug/L 0.044 v 0.053
Interventions
Randomized to immediate angiography or delayed angiography
Outcomes
Comparisons are immediate angiography vs. delayed angiography.
Primary Outcomes
- Survival at 90 days
- 64.5% vs. 67.2%% (OR 0.89; 95% CI 0.62-1.27)
Secondary Outcomes
- Survival with good cerebral performance or mild of moderate disability
- 62.9% vs. 64.4% (OR 0.94; 95% CI 0.66-1.31)
- CPC score at 90 days
- 1 57.7% vs. 60.2%
- 2 5.1% vs. 4.2$, OR 1.29 (0.56-2.92)
- 3 1.5% vs. 1.9%, OR 0.81 (0.21-3.07)
- 4 0% vs. 0.8%
- 5 35.7% vs. 68.7%, OR 0.85 (0.60-1.22)
- Survival until hospital discharge 65.2% vs. 68.7%, OR 0.85 (0.60-1.22)
- GCS score
- Median
- Geometric mean
- CPC Score
- TIMI major bleeding
- Recurrence of ventricular tachycardia resulting in defibrillation or electrical cardioversion
- Creatinine Kinase
- Median AUV
- Geometric mean
- Creatinine Kinase MB
- Median
- Geometric mean
- Troponin T
- Median
- Geometric mean
- Troponin I
- Median
- Geometric mean
- AKIN Stage
- Need for renal replacement therapy
- Time to target temperature
- Median
- Geometric mean
- Time to hypothermia
- Median
- Geometric mean
- Time to normothermia
- Median
- Geometric mean
- Duration of intortopic or catecholamine support
- Median
- Geometric mean
- Markers of shock
- Duration of mechanical ventilation
- Median
- Geometric mean
Subgroup Analysis
Adverse Events
Criticisms
Funding
Netherlands Heart Institute, Biotronik, and AstraZeneca.